Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Frank Kidd's avatar

Frank, I already have too many books... you've got to stop doing this.

Expand full comment
Philip “Big Philly” Smith's avatar

This is thought-provoking.

As much as I love pulp fiction, I’m always discerning which writers are still worth reading today. Someone like Bradbury surely transcended the movement. Same goes probably for Raymond Chandler. Others, like David Goodis, tried to explore morality and human failings within the noir framework.

I’m not coming at this as a literary snob but simply as a Christian. For example, the classic noir tale is just a retelling of Adam & Eve’s fall--cautionary tales that thrill, entertain, and illustrate the dangers of sin.

With guys like Spillane, I’m not sure if he’s only popular because he was that era’s “edgy” writer willing to challenge the acceptable bounds of morality at the time. (I’m thinking specifically of the subversive vs “superversive,” if you’re familiar).

I’m rambling, but this is always my challenge in how to conduct my life as both a reader and writer of faith. Very difficult to discern and probably a topic worthy of its own blog.

Excellent piece, as always, Frank.

Expand full comment
9 more comments...

No posts